What matters more in a relationship — shared interests or the ability to reach agreements: a psychotherapist's perspective

What do you think is essential for living happily ever after?
Undoubtedly, the cornerstone of a healthy relationship between a man and a woman is a shared set of values.
Care, personal growth, and a sense of loyalty — all of these form the foundation for a couple’s well-being and development. As for having "shared interests" I’ve always found that to be a rather loud claim. It’s as if people are talking about something inherently unlikely.
When individuals deliberately emphasize that they have many interests in common, it may indeed sound wonderful; however, it often raises more questions than it answers.
Sometimes such statements are an attempt to show that everything is fine, that there is something uniting them, even if reality suggests otherwise.

Different from the Start

What should we take into account as a foundation in this matter?
For instance, the initial differences in the basic configuration of the nervous system, hormonal rhythms, and ways of experiencing life.
Research shows that male and female psychobiology does indeed differ. Even during communication, entirely different processes are activated in each.
The foundation of any strong anxiety is rigid and extreme beliefs. They dictate to us how things "should" be, and any deviation from this course causes a storm.
  • Men tend to be more outwardly oriented: toward tasks, achievements, and recovery through activity or even complete solitude.
  • Women, on the other hand, are oriented toward connection, primarily emotional. They regulate themselves through communication, shared experiences, or a kind of "quiet" inner closeness. A woman needs to receive the energy of warmth in order to share it with others.
This is not about who is better or worse. It is about different ways of restoring energy and building inner resources. From this perspective, interests are more of an individual trait. They may overlap at times, but by nature they remain distinct.
For example, there are ways of relax: activity or solitude, life rhythm, forms of intimacy, communication, hobbies — all of these naturally differ. And that is normal. These differences are inevitable.

Two Truths We Hold

One of the key ideas is that psychological flexibility in relationships is the ability to hold two truths simultaneously.
In fact, this is what psychotherapy often aims for: learning to accept, without internal conflict, that you and your partner are different while still feeling that you are together.
These two polar truths are:
  • 1
    We are different
  • 2
    We are together
… and recognizing both realities creates the possibility for agreement.

About Needs, Not Sacrifice

When we speak about psychological flexibility, it’s important to focus on a key word: "needs".
This is not about giving yourself up. Rather, it’s about recognizing that your partner has a different way of experiencing joy, resting, living their life and even your shared life.

This does not mean your partner is against you. They are simply different: a different person, with different neural pathways and a different neurobiological makeup.

A Real-Life Example

For example, one partner (more often a man) enjoys activity, socializing, and being in company.

The woman may not object, she supports him but at the same time she may feel she lacks attention. Through silence and solitude, she is, in a way, asking: "Let's stay together. Let’s not go anywhere".
At that moment, the other partner may react with harshness.
Conversely, when the woman suggests something more intimate or home-centered, the man might respond: "I need to go out to see my friends".
This often leads to rigid interpretations: "You don’t love me", "You don’t understand me", — simply because "You don’t like the same things I do".
But the voice of flexibility sounds different: "It's important for me to be with you. I understand you, even if we restore ourselves in different ways. Let’s find a way of living that has space for both of us".
Then, for example, weekends can be structured differently: time for shared activities and time for rest. Sometimes — even time apart.
Instead of wasting energy on conflict, resentment, and feeling unheard, partners agree on a rhythm. Shared activities alternate with personal interests.
Intimacy in a couple is expressed in different ways, through different "languages". But both of these languages are recognized as valuable.

The Paradox of Living Relationships

Do you know what another psychological paradox is?
Differences in interests, combined with shared values, often make a relationship more vibrant. Partners do not mirror each other or suppress their needs. They are not forced to constantly adapt. On the contrary, they enrich their shared life with their differences.
In this way, closeness, love, and emotional warmth are not about identical interests — they are about the ability to reach agreements.
Each time, it is a new meeting between two people, even if they have been together for years. And that meeting is filled with the willingness to share something of one’s own. When we share, we expand another person’s life.

So, What’s the Bottom Line?

The ability to reach agreements in a close, trusting relationship is, on the one hand, the capacity to remain yourself and stay grounded in your own desires. On the other hand, it is allowing your partner to be different — and accepting that.

Even though you are different, you can still find a shared "us".
What is needed for this?
The foundation is quite simple: once we understand that we share core values, we can align our needs as a couple — what matters to each of us.
When we know our values match, we begin to understand each other’s desires.
  • My needs matter
  • Your needs matter too
And from this, space emerges for resolving shared issues without struggle or conflict.
The conclusion is simple: relationships are not sustained by shared interests, but by the ability to acknowledge differences and work with them over time.

It is this capacity to reach agreements that creates a sense of stability and inspires the desire to continue the relationship.
Because when the first conflict arises — "we have different interests", "we can’t agree" — psychological defenses kick in. People close off, distance themselves, and remain unheard.
If a relationship relies only on "shared interests" the distance between partners begins to grow. A breakup may even follow when there is no understanding that our differences actually contain a great deal of life.
Under one important condition: that our values align.
Invite Elina Landman
as a speaker
To request Elina Landman as a speaker for your upcoming event, please feel free to reach out via email: mail@landmanelina.com.

Elina looks forward to the opportunity to contribute to the success of your professional forum and engage with your audience in a meaningful way.
CONTACT
Fill out the form and or contact me
via the contacts below.
By clicking on the button, you consent to the processing of personal data and agree to the privacy policy