Why do we so often make choices out of obligation rather than genuine inner alignment? And how can we reclaim our ability to choose freely?
We hear a lot these days about the importance of following our desires. "Be clear about what you want." "Learn to dream." "Take everything life has to offer." These messages are everywhere. At the same time, we are constantly confronted with another set of expectations: "You should." "You have to." "That's how it’s done."
As a result, many people find themselves trapped in a difficult dilemma.
I suggest looking at it differently. The goal is not to choose one side and reject the other, but to understand where healthy responsibility ends and destructive obligation begins.
What Motivation Is Built On
In popular psychology, motivation is often described as resting on three pillars: "I want," "I can," and "I should." For a psychologically mature person, this framework can be extremely effective.
However, in my clinical practice I regularly encounter two common distortions.
- "I Want" without any "I should". This is pure immaturity. "I want people to give things to me."
"I want everything to happen my way." "I want to dream, but someone else should make those dreams come true." Without the willingness to take responsibility, desires remain nothing more than fantasies.
- "I should" without "I want". This is rigid obligation at its worst. A person becomes so focused on what they believe they must do that they stop listening to themselves. They act because "that's what’s expected," even though there is no inner resonance or personal meaning. Eventually, this way of living leads to burnout, anxiety, or emotional numbness.
Consider these examples: someone studies English because "it's necessary for my career," goes to the gym because "successful people are supposed to," and then wonders why they feel no energy or joy. The answer is simple: those actions were never truly their own choice.
Healthy Responsibility vs. Unhealthy Obligation
I am not suggesting that we eliminate the word "should". On the contrary, a mature person cannot live without conscious responsibility. But that responsibility must be grounded in meaning and personal values. It should be the kind of "should" that we choose for ourselves.
The next time you tell yourself, "I have to do this," pay attention. Do you experience inner resistance? Or do you genuinely feel that this matters to you and aligns with your values and long-term goals?
For example: taking the decision to become a parent.
Many women, at a certain age, begin to experience pressure: "I have to have a baby because my biological clock is ticking. "Everyone else already has children." "My parents are waiting for grandchildren."
This is an unhealthy form of "should." It is driven by fear of judgment, social expectations, and anxiety about falling behind.
If a woman enters motherhood from that emotional state, adapting to her new role may become incredibly difficult. She may have to rebuild its meaning from the ground up before obligation transforms into a genuine, warm relationship with her child.
Now imagine another scenario. A woman feels that she truly wants to become a mother. She has a loving partner and consciously chooses this path.
In this decision, both elements coexist: "I want" (I want this child) and healthy "I should" (I understand that my lifestyle will change, I will lose sleep, and I will take on responsibility). This version of "should" does not weigh her down. It supports her because she has chosen it freely.
A sense of duty is the clearest marker of unhealthy obligation.
At its core is always fear. Fear of being disapproved of. Fear of rejection. Fear of judgment. Fear of becoming an outsider, losing the acceptance of friends or colleagues, or failing to meet someone else’s standards.
People caught in this mindset are constantly running without knowing where they are headed. They move at full speed, trying to accomplish everything and control everything. "I have to submit the report, I have to lose weight before summer, I have to buy an apartment, I have to measure up."
But there is no real choice behind the race, and the finish line keeps moving farther away.
Pay attention to the language you use. "I have to put up with my husband." "I have to tolerate unfair treatment at work." "I'm enduring this city, this weather, this pace of life."
The phrase "I'm putting up with it" is often a reliable sign that you are acting from obligation rather than choice.
No matter what goal you achieve under those circumstances, it is unlikely to bring satisfaction. Deep down, one feeling remains: "I did it—but I never really wanted to."
How to Tell the Difference Between Choice and Obligation
In my work with clients, I rely on several simple but powerful filters. Ask yourself these questions whenever you face an important decision — or even an everyday one.
- "Is this truly mine, or am I afraid of the consequences?" Imagine an 18-year-old choosing a university. His parents insist on one career path, but he feels it is not right for him. Still, he worries about ending up unsuccessful or embarrassing his family.
Asking "Is this truly mine?" helps separate authentic desire from fear of conflict. If the honest answer is "I'm afraid of the consequences," then what you are dealing with is unhealthy obligation.
- "Am I acting out of love or out of fear?"Fear of judgment. Fear of not measuring up. Fear of not being accepted. If you recognize even one of these motivations, you are probably acting from a sense of duty rather than genuine choice. And obligation rarely leads to fulfillment.
- "Would I still do this if no one ever noticed?" Imagine making coffee for yourself in a traditional Turkish coffee pot. No one will admire the beautiful foam. No one will like the photo on social media. No one will compliment your taste. Would you still prepare it that way?
If the answer is yes, then this is your own authentic desire. If you only make the breakfast for a picture and the approval of your followers, you are performing for external validation.
Liz from Eat, Pray, Love
Consider the story of Elizabeth Gilbert’s Eat, Pray, Love.
At the beginning of the book — and the film adaptation — Liz appears to have a perfectly successful life. She has a husband, a stable home, and a predictable future.
From the outside, she seems to have everything. Her family, friends, and society all agree: "This is what success looks like." Yet inside she feels empty.
One of the most powerful ideas in the story is that the hardest realization is recognizing that you are living the "right" life while not truly living your own. Another unforgettable line captures the dilemma perfectly: "I was supposed to want all of this, but I didn’t."
That is the classic trap of unhealthy obligation. All the outward markers of a successful life exist — but they are disconnected from any genuine inner response.
Liz’s decision to leave and travel the world is not an escape from her problems or an immature whim. It is a mature act of choice.
She takes responsibility for her own life, lets go of other people’s expectations and the fear of judgment, and begins searching for what genuinely resonates with her.
It is a clear example of moving from obligation toward self-trust.
She takes responsibility for her own life, lets go of other people’s expectations and the fear of judgment, and begins searching for what genuinely resonates with her.
It is a clear example of moving from obligation toward self-trust.
Many people fear taking such a step because it requires embracing uncertainty. Yet admitting that you are living someone else’s life is often far more frightening than continuing to fulfill obligations on autopilot. And that recognition is the first real step toward freedom.
How to Return to a State Where You Act from Inner Alignment Rather Than Obligation
1
Stop treating "want" and "should" as enemies
They can — and should — work together. Healthy responsibility grows out of conscious choice, and conscious choice grows out of your values.
Take time to identify what truly matters to you. Security? Growth? Care? Creativity? Recognition? When your actions are rooted in your own values, many "shoulds" stop feeling burdensome.
2
Learn to recognize fear
Whenever anxiety arises before making a decision, ask yourself: "What exactly am I afraid of?" Judgment? Loss of status? What other people will think? Naming the fear does not eliminate it, but it stops allowing fear to operate as an invisible dictator.
3
Practice small acts of choice
Make yourself coffee simply because you enjoy it. Go to see the movie that genuinely interests you — not the one everyone is talking about. Say "no" to a request if your honest answer is no.
The more often you exercise your capacity to choose in everyday situations, the easier it becomes when facing life-changing decisions.
A sense of duty alone does not make you a good person. Conscious choice is what makes you free. You do not need to eliminate "should" from your life entirely. You simply need to give it back its soul — the "want" that may have frozen over long ago but is still capable of thawing.
Invite Elina Landman
as a speaker
as a speaker
To request Elina Landman as a speaker for your upcoming event, please feel free to reach out via email: mail@landmanelina.com.
Elina looks forward to the opportunity to contribute to the success of your professional forum and engage with your audience in a meaningful way.
Elina looks forward to the opportunity to contribute to the success of your professional forum and engage with your audience in a meaningful way.
CONTACT
Fill out the form and or contact me
via the contacts below.
via the contacts below.
By clicking on the button, you consent to the processing of personal data and agree to the privacy policy